all over the United States. One elderly Hugh Stiver resided in Uruguay.
My Hugh was elusive or reclusive—or perhaps had changed his name? I searched for Hugh Cutler, Cutler being the Stiver siblings' surname prior to the arrival in the household of Anson Stiver. Seven of these turned up; one was the right age, thirty-two. This Hugh Cutler was a mechanic at a garage in Arlington, Massachusetts. He had no Facebook page, and I found him through court records; Cutler was on probation following his conviction a year earlier for assault.
I phoned Jennifer Stiver. "Hey, thanks for your help today.
I just have a quick question. Was your brother Hugh a mechanic?"
"Yes, but I can't talk to you anymore. I'm just too...ambivalent about what you're doing. I'm hanging up.
Sorry."
And she was gone. So I couldn't ask her if she knew that Hugh apparently had a violent streak.
I finished the soup and salad.
I tried Virgil Jackman, reached his voice mail, and left no message.
105
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
Janie Insinger did answer her phone. She said she and Kev were "like, going out," and she could speak to me briefly.
"Just one question, Janie. When you were interviewed by the police after Greg's death, you told them he had been despondent. That was in the police report. Did you also mention his relationship with Kenyon Louderbush?"
"You bet we did. Why not? I was so ripshit, I didn't give a crap if he was some senator or if he was just some pissant geek."
"And the police noted this and asked you more about it?
The physical abuse, for example...did that come up?"
"Sure, but this old bald guy detective—I forget his name—
he just said that wasn't anything the cops could, like, get mixed up in. It was private. He said it used to be different, but nowadays the police didn't care about gay people and their private business. The new chief would just say it was none of the police's business."
"Uh-huh. Was this a Detective Nichols, do you remember?"
"Coulda been. He had hair coming out of his ears."
This would make him easy to find. Bald and hairy. "What about Greg's brother, Hugh? Did Greg ever talk about him to you? Hugh was a couple of years older."
"Greg had a brother? I didn't know that. Are you sure?"
"Yes. I heard about him from Jennifer. Hugh left Schenectady when he was eighteen."
"Greg never talked about him. They probably weren't close."
"Is Anthony still with you, the security guy from the campaign?"
106
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
"He's downstairs. Kev doesn't like him around, so we might give him the night off. Virgil probably would've tried to get him in the sack with us, but Kev is too straight for that, thank God."
"Well, be careful."
"You too."
I reread the police report. Why wasn't Insinger's mention of Louderbush in there? The cop would have known that Louderbush was a big cheese in the Legislature, so apparently discretion had overridden conscientiousness.
My Blackberry alerted me that something had come in from Bud Giannopolous, and I checked the laptop. This was timely. The sizeable file was the Shenango Life Insurance Company report on the death of its policyholder, Gregory Stiver. The nine-page report by investigator Lorraine Fallon included the SUNY security and Albany Police findings and the APD verdict of suicide. In a "note to the files," Fallon wrote that a handwritten "addendum" to the police report labeled CONFIDENTIAL mentioned "a physically abusive male/male relationship" and "the possibility of foul play," rather than suicide. Fallon noted additionally, "Conversation with Nichols/APD. Suggest destroy copy. Unsubstantiated.
Libelous? Leg. kahuna."
The copy of this handwritten addendum was missing from the insurance company's copy of the police report, as it was from my copy. The SUNY security report did include the scribbled note, "Call from Leg. Blessing responding." In her report, Fallon made no mention of this cryptic
My Hugh was elusive or reclusive—or perhaps had changed his name? I searched for Hugh Cutler, Cutler being the Stiver siblings' surname prior to the arrival in the household of Anson Stiver. Seven of these turned up; one was the right age, thirty-two. This Hugh Cutler was a mechanic at a garage in Arlington, Massachusetts. He had no Facebook page, and I found him through court records; Cutler was on probation following his conviction a year earlier for assault.
I phoned Jennifer Stiver. "Hey, thanks for your help today.
I just have a quick question. Was your brother Hugh a mechanic?"
"Yes, but I can't talk to you anymore. I'm just too...ambivalent about what you're doing. I'm hanging up.
Sorry."
And she was gone. So I couldn't ask her if she knew that Hugh apparently had a violent streak.
I finished the soup and salad.
I tried Virgil Jackman, reached his voice mail, and left no message.
105
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
Janie Insinger did answer her phone. She said she and Kev were "like, going out," and she could speak to me briefly.
"Just one question, Janie. When you were interviewed by the police after Greg's death, you told them he had been despondent. That was in the police report. Did you also mention his relationship with Kenyon Louderbush?"
"You bet we did. Why not? I was so ripshit, I didn't give a crap if he was some senator or if he was just some pissant geek."
"And the police noted this and asked you more about it?
The physical abuse, for example...did that come up?"
"Sure, but this old bald guy detective—I forget his name—
he just said that wasn't anything the cops could, like, get mixed up in. It was private. He said it used to be different, but nowadays the police didn't care about gay people and their private business. The new chief would just say it was none of the police's business."
"Uh-huh. Was this a Detective Nichols, do you remember?"
"Coulda been. He had hair coming out of his ears."
This would make him easy to find. Bald and hairy. "What about Greg's brother, Hugh? Did Greg ever talk about him to you? Hugh was a couple of years older."
"Greg had a brother? I didn't know that. Are you sure?"
"Yes. I heard about him from Jennifer. Hugh left Schenectady when he was eighteen."
"Greg never talked about him. They probably weren't close."
"Is Anthony still with you, the security guy from the campaign?"
106
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
"He's downstairs. Kev doesn't like him around, so we might give him the night off. Virgil probably would've tried to get him in the sack with us, but Kev is too straight for that, thank God."
"Well, be careful."
"You too."
I reread the police report. Why wasn't Insinger's mention of Louderbush in there? The cop would have known that Louderbush was a big cheese in the Legislature, so apparently discretion had overridden conscientiousness.
My Blackberry alerted me that something had come in from Bud Giannopolous, and I checked the laptop. This was timely. The sizeable file was the Shenango Life Insurance Company report on the death of its policyholder, Gregory Stiver. The nine-page report by investigator Lorraine Fallon included the SUNY security and Albany Police findings and the APD verdict of suicide. In a "note to the files," Fallon wrote that a handwritten "addendum" to the police report labeled CONFIDENTIAL mentioned "a physically abusive male/male relationship" and "the possibility of foul play," rather than suicide. Fallon noted additionally, "Conversation with Nichols/APD. Suggest destroy copy. Unsubstantiated.
Libelous? Leg. kahuna."
The copy of this handwritten addendum was missing from the insurance company's copy of the police report, as it was from my copy. The SUNY security report did include the scribbled note, "Call from Leg. Blessing responding." In her report, Fallon made no mention of this cryptic
Similar Books
