He felt that he was being patronized. When I had finished playing, he made some polite remarks, and a little while after that, he took his leave.
Then, as always, I was sensitive to his every mood and action. Father was not. After he had seen Ben to the door, he turned to me, rubbing his hands with delight and grinning, and asked me,
âWell, what do you think of your unwashed digger now?ââfor all the world as if Ben was something he had created specially for that evening.
âI think thatâs a dreadful way to characterize him!â
âHoney,â he cried, exploding with laughter, âthat was your characterization, not mine.â
âAt least I want to forget it.â
âThen he got through to you.â
âI found him quite interesting,â I said demurely. âI just wonder what happened when I was playing. He became very surly and unhappy, I think.â
âDid he? Well, a young manâs to be forgiven his moods. The point is, heâs quite a man with quite a mind. Youâll agree to that, wonât you?â
âHeâs certainly the most opinionated young man I ever met.â
âYou mean that he has opinions and voices them. Thatâs not exactly the same thing as being opinionated.â
âHeâs very sure of himself.â
âAnd with reason,â Father said. âHeâs had no one to depend on but himself.â
Should I have told Father that I was in love? It was something I hardly dared to admit to myselfâthat for the first time in my life, I wanted a person so desperately that I could not think of anything but Ben Holt. I donât believe that these things are accidents. If I had left it alone, perhaps I would never have seen him again, although Ben insisted that he was already in love with me. But that was after the fact, and people love differently, and to be in loveâif indeed he wasâmeant something else to Ben than it meant to me.
So here is a whole day, another day, gone with my writing, dear Alvin, and now for the first time, this journey so far back into the past is beginning to trouble me just a little. But I will finish it as truthfully as I know how, which is little less than truthful. I mean that the Dorothy Aimesley and the Ben Holt I write about are like two people I have read about or been told about. Have you ever remarked on the fact that in a dream you will see yourself in the third person, so to speak? This remembering is somewhat like a dream.
Â
5
Two days, and I have written nothing, but I have gone back into a past I never thought I would revisit. What sort of people are we, Alvin, that we look upon growing old with such skepticism and fearâyet avoid the past as the plague and revisit it with even greater fear? But I have been prowling over the old house, going through drawers and rummaging in the attic, and I have even wept a little over this and that. In my old bedroom, just where I had placed it more than forty years ago, I found a long, long letter from Ben, and I am sending it to you but in its proper place. You may peruse its intimacies without embarrassment and use it just as your own judgment dictates.
I thought that I had the letter I wrote to Ben after the Sunday evening I spoke of above; I had some notion that he kept it and gave it back to me some time later. Well, perhaps he didâor perhaps he threw it away. Ben did not suffer from sentimentalismâand I mean that more as praise than criticism. In any case, I could not find it, but I remember the general tenor of it. The evening after, Monday evening, I wrote to him:
Dear Mr. Holt:
I enjoyed our evening with you, and would like to see you again, if you can find time. Since I am leaving for school soon, I have only this coming Sunday free. If your day is also free, I think it might be nice to pack a picnic basket and spend the day out of doors. Providing the weather is suitable. If you can let me know
Immortal Angel
O.L. Casper
John Dechancie
Ben Galley
Jeanne C. Stein
Jeremiah D. Schmidt
Becky McGraw
John Schettler
Antonia Frost
Michael Cadnum