Hamilton. Neither of us is going to be put down by the hardball tactics you and your Federalist cronies consistently enlist in trying to subvert my Constitution.
HAMILTON:
Your
Constitution? The last time I checked I wrote fifty-two of the Federalist Papers in support of its ratification. You wrote how many?
(Silence.)
MADISON: Iâm not going to respond.
HAMILTON: How many?
MADISON: Iâm not taking the bait again.
HAMILTON: Twenty-six, is it?
MADISON: Twenty-eight!!
HAMILTON: Oooh, big man with twenty-eight Federalist Papers under his belt. Iâm sooo impressed.
MADISON: You know, Hamilton, youâre not just a bastard. Youâre a total arsehole.
HAMILTON: Hey, Iâd rather be an arsehole than have my lips locked around Jeffersonâs codger 24/7!
MADISON: I hope you get shot.
BUZZY: Mr. Hamilton, Mr. Madison, please!! Can we stick to the issues?
MADISON: He started it.
HAMILTON: Sorry, but the numbers donât lie. Itâs twenty-six, right?
MADISON: Twenty-eight!!
TODDY: Enough, gentlemen. Now, Buzzy, hereâs the way I see it: The President
may
have reason to be nervous about France or any other foreign power who might benefit from discord in this country.
BUZZY: Yes, Toddy, national security is of the utmost importance but I really donât think criticizing our government is going to make France more likely to invade us. My fear is that the Federalist Party may want these acts signed into law so that they can consolidate power and avoid any criticism at all.
TODDY: Buzzy, thatâs an absolutely valid concern and one that Iâll bring to President Adamsâs attention. But grant that an unfettered freedom to criticize the government does smack of mob rule. And who trusts a mob?
BUZZY: I certainly donât. But trying to suppress a âmobâ is only going to create more dissent.
TODDY: True, true.
BUZZY: People will only want more freedom more quickly. Besides, inevitably this Republic will become a true democracy as more people are given the right to vote.
TODDY: I certainly concede that point. But until then how do we balance security concerns with liberty?
BUZZY: Well, I think we should agree that
treasonous
acts are outlawedâacts of deliberate betrayal against the government, rather than written words that purportedly incite rebellion.
TODDY: That, my friend, sounds like a fair compromise. We certainly donât want to violate a central freedom we just fought so hard to safeguard. It would be too too ironic. I think we should also engage the French and English in strict policies of neutrality to minimize threats from overseas.
BUZZY: Good point. That is what President Washington advised us in his Farewell Address.
TODDY: Then itâs settled. Now this has been a very fruitful discussion. Mr. Hamilton, what do you think? Mr. Hamilton?
BUZZY: Mr. Hamilton?
HAMILTON: Was someone talking?
BUZZY: Well, yes. We were just having what I think was a productive discussion.
HAMILTON: Thatâs great because I was just having what I think was a productive naptime.
BUZZY: Mr. Madison, do you have any thoughts?
MADISON: Yes. First of all, this show is in trouble. Youâre doing it all wrong.
TODDY: How would you prefer we behave?
MADISON: Oh, I donât know. Like dogs? Call Buzzy a mongrel.
HAMILTON: Maybe bite him.
MADISON: At least bark.
HAMILTON: Thereâs more barking on
The Burr Factor
and they just have one host. No wonder more people show up at their town square.
MADISON: You should try to rip his throat out.
(Hamilton laughs.)
MADISON: Whatâs so funny?
HAMILTON: Iâm trying to imagine you ripping someoneâs throat out. How tall are you? Twenty-six inches?
MADISON: Twenty-eight!!!
(Madison lunges at Hamilton.)
BUZZY: Oh dear.
TODDY: Please join us tomorrow when our guests will discuss this yearâs wedge issue, the three-fifths clause of the Constitution.
It was quite a read. The hosts were so
Connor Kostick
Randy Chandler
Alistair Horne
Juli Page Morgan
David Nasaw
Simon Hawke
Erin McKean
Lauren Willig
Nora Okja Keller
J. M. Gregson