youâve got sore feet.â
But Mary wouldnât listen to either her mother or her father. The truth was, she enjoyed the attention Ben and Isaac paid her. They brought her the best rewards from their hunts and kept her in food and fur. The sad fact of the matter was both Maryâs mother and father also enjoyed the food Ben and Isaac provided and their grumbling bellies stopped them from nagging Mary any further.
But Ben and Isaac were growing impatient.
âYou have to choose one of us,â they demanded.
âI love you both,â Mary said.
Did she mean it or was she only being fickle? Itâs hard to know for sure. The heart is made of a hard-packed ground. Thereâs no hunter with an eye sharp enough to track a trail across such counâtry and know for sure that heâs heading in the right direction.
The two friends finally had enough. On a hot August day, after a glass of cold buttermilk, they swore that theyâd put an end to their quarrelling and competition once and for all.
âWeâll fight for Maryâs hand,â Ben said. âThe two of us will square off and the winner takes all.â
So they called upon the town blacksmith who forged an iron chain and drove it into both sides of a sturdy red maple stump. Each of the two suitors was shackled to one end of the chain with his left hand tied behind his back.
âWe were bonded in life,â said Isaac. âWeâll be bonded in death.â
âWeâll fight to the end,â said Ben. âAnd the winner will take the hand of Mary Well of the Magaguadavic.â
The townsfolk gathered to watch the battle. Today someone might have tried to stop them, or possibly dialled for the police, but these were simpler and harder times. If two men decided to fight, no one would do or say anything about it. Life went on â and no one wanted to miss a show like this.
High upon her front porch, Mary Well stood between her mother and father. She was both flattered and excited at the prospect of the duel fought on her behalf. The two men, armed with their hunting knives, stood face to face over the red maple stump they were chained to. They fought, wielding their huntâing knives with practised ruthlessness. Ben was cut in the left shoulder and blood ran down his arm like a long red scarf, but he caught Isaac with a slash in the leg that painted Isaacâs trouâsers scarlet red.
âYield and give,â Ben said, menacing Isaac with his knife. âThat cut was close to the blood-pipe, I warrant. Youâll run yourâself dry before the end of an hour.â
âYour own wound is closer to the heart than mine. Youâll be lying in the dirt, cold and pale, while Iâm still standing,â Isaac predicted. âPut down your knife and letâs call it quits.â
The truth was neither of the men wanted to hurt the other more than they already had. They had known each other for many years, and as much as they loved Mary they also cared for each other. But both men were stubborn New Brunswickers who didnât give up easily when pushed to it.
Mary knew that too. At first sheâd been excited to see the two friends fighting for her attention, but now the whole situation had changed. She didnât want them to hurt each other. She didnât want to be the one to blame if either man was killed.
âStop!â Mary shouted.
Now here is where individual versions of the tale begin to difâfer. Some folks say that Mary keeled over in her parentâs arms, stone dead from a stroke. Other folks claim that Mary ran out to stop the fight and was caught by an accidental knife swing from either Ben or Isaac.
At least I hope it was accidental. A fight to the death brings out strange emotionsâ although some might think it impossible that a man who starts out fighting for someone could end up hurting them, stranger things have happened. The human heart can be as dark
Lauraine Snelling
Paullina Simons
Lauren Blakely
Jane Christmas
Jl Paul
Monica Murphy
O.R. Melling
Laura Childs
Shirley McKay
Russell Banks