“goofy.” But he had never had sex before meeting Kaitlynn Kelly, and a look at what he has posted on a social media site suggests that he was a frustrated, involuntary celibate. On January 11, 2011, Smith posted a line from the animated sitcom
Family Guy
on his Facebook page: “women are not people god just put them here for mans entertainment.”
When a Facebook friend commented that the actual line is “Women are not people. They are devices built by the Lord JesusChrist for our entertainment,” Smith replied, “Ahhh I wish I had that power.”
—
AFTER OFFICER KRASTEL visited her dormitory, Kaitlynn Kelly was asked to come downtown to the police station to talk to Detective Connie Brueckner, a highly regarded, eight-year veteran of the Missoula police force. The interview, which was recorded, lasted forty-two minutes. Brueckner was thorough, and asked probing questions, but she presented them in a sensitive, supportive manner. When Kelly admitted that she had agreed to have sex with Calvin Smith before they entered her dorm, Brueckner inquired, “What were you thinking at that time?”
“That it was going to be a good time,” Kelly replied.
“What did you think was going to happen?”
“Probably, maybe, have sex.”
“Were you okay with that idea at the time?”
“I was,” Kelly answered. “That’s why I let him in my room.”
“Did that change?” Brueckner asked. “That feeling?”
“Yeah,” Kelly said. “I guess when we got in my room. Because my roommate and her boyfriend were in the room. They were, like, snoring. Passed out. And I told him, ‘My roommate and her boyfriend are here. We can’t do anything.’ And he told me, ‘It’s okay. We’ll be quiet.’ ”
“What did you think of that?” Brueckner asked.
“Not okay,” Kelly answered.
Detective Brueckner assured Kaitlynn Kelly that it was understandable and acceptable for her to have changed her mind about having sex once they entered the dorm room. Then she asked Kelly, “If your roommate wasn’t there, would you have been okay with it?”
“No,” Kelly declared without hesitating. “As soon as we walked in the dorm, I was like, ‘No! I don’t want to do this.’…I told him, ‘You can just lay on my bed until the morning.’ ”
“And what did he say to that?” Brueckner asked.
“Well, he got on my bed and lay down,” Kelly answered. “And I got next to him and lay down.”
Detective Brueckner asked if she and Calvin Smith went to bed with their clothes on.
“Yes,” Kelly answered. “I don’t know what happened after that, but the next thing I remember is waking up with his fingers inside of me, with a stabbing motion, very roughly.”
“Inside your vagina?”
“Yes,” Kelly said.
Brueckner asked what happened to the clothing she had been wearing when she got in bed.
“When I woke up?” Kelly said. “I didn’t have pants on, but my shirt was still on.”
“And what happened when you realized that was happening?” Brueckner asked.
“I kept reaching for his hand and pulling it away,” Kelly explained, demonstrating with her hands. “I kept grabbing at his thumb and pulling, like, towards him. To get him off of me. But he kept, like, coming back.”
“Did he say anything?” Detective Brueckner asked.
According to Kaitlynn Kelly, Calvin Smith told her, “No, just wait. Just wait.”
“Were you saying anything?” Brueckner asked.
“I was saying, ‘Stop!’ ” Kelly insisted. “And then—”
“How loud were you guys?” Brueckner interrupted.
“I don’t think I was very loud,” Kelly replied. She paused for a moment before explaining, ruefully, “Because my roommate was there, I didn’t want to wake them up. I just wanted it to stop. And then he went in my rear, with his hands doing the same stabbing motion.”
A little later, Detective Brueckner again inquired why Kaitlynn Kelly hadn’t done more to alert her roommate and her roommate’s boyfriend, who
Family Guy
on his Facebook page: “women are not people god just put them here for mans entertainment.”
When a Facebook friend commented that the actual line is “Women are not people. They are devices built by the Lord JesusChrist for our entertainment,” Smith replied, “Ahhh I wish I had that power.”
—
AFTER OFFICER KRASTEL visited her dormitory, Kaitlynn Kelly was asked to come downtown to the police station to talk to Detective Connie Brueckner, a highly regarded, eight-year veteran of the Missoula police force. The interview, which was recorded, lasted forty-two minutes. Brueckner was thorough, and asked probing questions, but she presented them in a sensitive, supportive manner. When Kelly admitted that she had agreed to have sex with Calvin Smith before they entered her dorm, Brueckner inquired, “What were you thinking at that time?”
“That it was going to be a good time,” Kelly replied.
“What did you think was going to happen?”
“Probably, maybe, have sex.”
“Were you okay with that idea at the time?”
“I was,” Kelly answered. “That’s why I let him in my room.”
“Did that change?” Brueckner asked. “That feeling?”
“Yeah,” Kelly said. “I guess when we got in my room. Because my roommate and her boyfriend were in the room. They were, like, snoring. Passed out. And I told him, ‘My roommate and her boyfriend are here. We can’t do anything.’ And he told me, ‘It’s okay. We’ll be quiet.’ ”
“What did you think of that?” Brueckner asked.
“Not okay,” Kelly answered.
Detective Brueckner assured Kaitlynn Kelly that it was understandable and acceptable for her to have changed her mind about having sex once they entered the dorm room. Then she asked Kelly, “If your roommate wasn’t there, would you have been okay with it?”
“No,” Kelly declared without hesitating. “As soon as we walked in the dorm, I was like, ‘No! I don’t want to do this.’…I told him, ‘You can just lay on my bed until the morning.’ ”
“And what did he say to that?” Brueckner asked.
“Well, he got on my bed and lay down,” Kelly answered. “And I got next to him and lay down.”
Detective Brueckner asked if she and Calvin Smith went to bed with their clothes on.
“Yes,” Kelly answered. “I don’t know what happened after that, but the next thing I remember is waking up with his fingers inside of me, with a stabbing motion, very roughly.”
“Inside your vagina?”
“Yes,” Kelly said.
Brueckner asked what happened to the clothing she had been wearing when she got in bed.
“When I woke up?” Kelly said. “I didn’t have pants on, but my shirt was still on.”
“And what happened when you realized that was happening?” Brueckner asked.
“I kept reaching for his hand and pulling it away,” Kelly explained, demonstrating with her hands. “I kept grabbing at his thumb and pulling, like, towards him. To get him off of me. But he kept, like, coming back.”
“Did he say anything?” Detective Brueckner asked.
According to Kaitlynn Kelly, Calvin Smith told her, “No, just wait. Just wait.”
“Were you saying anything?” Brueckner asked.
“I was saying, ‘Stop!’ ” Kelly insisted. “And then—”
“How loud were you guys?” Brueckner interrupted.
“I don’t think I was very loud,” Kelly replied. She paused for a moment before explaining, ruefully, “Because my roommate was there, I didn’t want to wake them up. I just wanted it to stop. And then he went in my rear, with his hands doing the same stabbing motion.”
A little later, Detective Brueckner again inquired why Kaitlynn Kelly hadn’t done more to alert her roommate and her roommate’s boyfriend, who
Similar Books
